Shirley Temple

Shirley Temple
Ryan Liebe for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Victoria Granof.
Rating
4(159)
Notes
Read community notes

This beloved kids’ drink was named after the late child star Shirley Temple Black, although she had no involvement in its invention in the 1930s. Saccharine to many adult palates, the grenadine-and-soda mocktail feels grown-up to kids, who delight at its bright red color, cherry garnish and hefty sugar content. (An adult version named the Dirty Shirley tempers its sweetness with the addition of vodka.) There’s no right answer to the debate surrounding lemon-lime soda (like Sprite or 7Up) versus ginger ale. Haley Traub, the general manager of the cocktail bar Attaboy on Manhattan’s Lower East Side, suspects the divergence is regional. Growing up in Minnesota, she says “it was always Sprite. It wasn’t until I moved to the East Coast that I’d ever heard it being made with ginger ale.” Soda options vary, but there is one nonnegotiable here: a cherry on top.

Featured in: Is the Dirty Shirley the Drink of the Summer?

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement


Ingredients

Yield:1 drink
  • Ice
  • 1ounce grenadine
  • 8ounces lemon-lime soda (such as Sprite or 7Up) or ginger ale
  • 1maraschino cherry, for garnish
Ingredient Substitution Guide

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Fill a highball or other tall, narrow glass with ice. Add grenadine, then top with soda. Garnish with a maraschino cherry.

Ratings

4 out of 5
159 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

We ordered them as kids in the 70s in MA and they were made with ginger ale and grenadine and always garnished with a cherry AND an orange slice. A Roy Rodgers is similar, but has Coke/Pepsi as the soda. Good times!

Grew up on Shirley Temple's in the '70's. We always used ginger ale. This is a much beloved drink in our family, my sister will still order one today as a mocktail if she doesn't want a boozy drink, and our nieces and nephews always clamor for a sip.

This might be a Canadian thing, but Shirley Temples here are made with lemon-lime soda, orange juice and grenadine. Same goes for the Roy Rogers. Sounds gross but I can tell you, I have drank many in my childhood (and my kids less so).

1970s suburban Boston bartenders, from the fancy Chinese restaurants to the family Italian joints, served these up with ginger ale. Always with a cherry and often with a groovy little cocktail spear.

My grandkids have been enjoying these “ kiddie cocktails” since were in preschool. When they visit, they would head for the drawer with the “kiddie glasses” and paper cocktail umbrellas, get out one jar of maraschino cherry and a can of 7 Up and start mixing. Forget the grenadine, the cherry juice worked fine. And 1 cherry on top? Forget it! The more the better. Some of them are now in their early 20s and occasionally will relive their childhood with a kiddie cocktail.

Still my favorite - at 80 years old.

We make "Juniors" for our daughter (named after the oldest brother on the show Blackish). 1 oz grenadine, a couple of ounces of a fruit juice like Cranberry, and then fill with whatever soda water we have on hand.

Grew up in Michigan with ginger ale as the soda….

My Boston family made them with Ginger Ale and Angostura Bitters with a Cherry

When we feel like making it fancier, we add a splash of lime juice and a splash of orange juice to create some extra flavor! It’s super good - highly recommend.

I am nursing an injury to my hip, and for the time being the pain medication I take means no alcohol--absolutely none. I miss a gin and tonic or a nice craft beer in the late afternoon in this beastly heat, and I came here in search of alternatives. Arnold Palmers and peach lemonade sound delicious. This recipe caught my eye, and I became eight years old again, sitting with my parents at some officers' club or other, on my best behavior, sipping my grown-up cocktail. I'm making one today.

For my cousin's wedding, I was in charge of the guest book. I made a fancy dress (I've been sewing since I was 4) with pearly buttons, I remember it clearly. I must have been 10. I had to go table to table with the book and get every one to sign. When I was done, and gone back to my table, dad got me a Shirley Temple. I felt SO grown up!

I make it with sparkling apple juice.

My beloved late dad would always make these for the kids when we had company — in the good cocktail glasses, which always drove my mother wild. Yet no one ever broke a glass and the kids loved being treated like grown-ups. Even though I graduated to Daddy’s excellent gin and tonics once I was old enough (Bombay Sapphire, Canada Dry tonic, fresh lime and mint), I still miss those Shirley Temples in the good glasses.

In 70's CA, Shirley Temples were always made with 7-up and Coke/Pepsi for a Roy Rogers. It's still a favorite since I don't drink, yet now most restaurants now serve it with Sprite, since they carry Coke products.

Shirley Temples were always 7-up for me until Sprite came out and carried by most bartenders. I still prefer 7-up. I've had it fancy with real cherry juice and grew up with grenadine, both are great. Just don't scrimp on the grenadine or the cherries. One cherry is never enough!

Still my favorite - at 80 years old.

My kids called them Swirly Temples. And always asked for 3 or 4 cherries from the bartender

Ginger Ale and a dash of bitters was the version I grew up with, the cherry was required, but for fancy A half slice of orange was added as well.

My Boston family made them with Ginger Ale and Angostura Bitters with a Cherry

I grew up in Newark, N.J. in the 50's. My father loved to take the family to Harry's, a bar with a dining room on the side. The waitress always took drink orders first, and my father always ordered a Shirley Temple for me. Ginger ale in a tall glass, lots of ice, a big fat maraschino cherry on top ( a hard decision whether to eat that cherry first, or savor it slowly after all the ginger ale was gone). Today I would be happy to order for myself the same - except I would double the cherry!

1970s suburban Boston bartenders, from the fancy Chinese restaurants to the family Italian joints, served these up with ginger ale. Always with a cherry and often with a groovy little cocktail spear.

This might be a Canadian thing, but Shirley Temples here are made with lemon-lime soda, orange juice and grenadine. Same goes for the Roy Rogers. Sounds gross but I can tell you, I have drank many in my childhood (and my kids less so).

Yes to the splash of OJ! I’m in Minnesota, so maybe it’s just proximity to Canada, but I prefer it this way.

My grandkids have been enjoying these “ kiddie cocktails” since were in preschool. When they visit, they would head for the drawer with the “kiddie glasses” and paper cocktail umbrellas, get out one jar of maraschino cherry and a can of 7 Up and start mixing. Forget the grenadine, the cherry juice worked fine. And 1 cherry on top? Forget it! The more the better. Some of them are now in their early 20s and occasionally will relive their childhood with a kiddie cocktail.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.