Most popular of all time
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Squidward's Suicide | 1240+ | u/SuicideSquidward | |
| BEN Drowned | 1200+ | Suggested Reading | Alex Hall (Jadusable) |
| The Russian Sleep Experiment | 1060+ | PotM | |
| Smile Dog | 850+ | Suggested Reading | Michael Lutz |
| Lavender Town Syndrome | 760+ | ||
| The Slender Man | 600+ | Suggested Reading | Eric Knudsen (Victor Surge) |
| The Rake | 590+ | Suggested Reading | |
| Username: 666 | 440+ | nana825763 | |
| Suicidemouse.avi | 425+ | ||
| NoEnd House | 420+ | PotM | Brian Russell |
| Normal Porn for Normal People | 390+ | PotM | Cosbydaf |
| Penpal | 390+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
u/1000Vultures |
| Herobrine | 390+ | ||
| The Rugrats Theory | 350+ | ||
| Dead Bart | 320+ | KI Simpson | |
| Candle Cove | 310+ | Suggested Reading | Kris Staub |
| Tomino's Hell | 310+ | Yaso Saijō | |
| Mereana Mordegard Glesgorv | 280+ | ||
| Rap Rat | 280+ | CanadianCowboy | |
| Midnight Game | 280+ |
By year
2013
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teeth.jpg |
190+ | PotM | |
| The Devil Game | 140+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
Casey Pierce (InfernalNightmare333) |
| Have You Seen This Man? | 140+ | ||
| Autopilot | 130+ | Suggested Reading | u/Skarjo |
| Gregory's Room | 120+ | seinfeldspitstain and TheDeigo908 | |
| Plankton Got Served | 120+ | Nakisions | |
| Ronald McDonald House | 110+ | Dkingsbury | |
| A Short Minecraft Rant | 100+ | Wolfenmaus | |
| Burgrr Entries | 100+ | Suggested Reading | Bogleech |
| Operation Stingray | 90+ | PotM | u/Jaunt-701 |
2014
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| annie96 is typing... | 270+ | PotM | Pascal Chatterjee |
| Necrosleep | 270+ | PotM | Lemniscate64 |
| Blind Maiden Website | 140+ | PotM | SpaceManiac888 |
| My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook |
130+ | PotM | u/natesw |
| Channel ∞ | 130+ | PotM | |
| The Sandman | 120+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
Tam Lin |
| When Gods Blink | 90+ | PotM | CharminglyShallow |
| The Harbinger Experiment | 80+ | PotM | Zyon J. (PerfectCircle35) |
| Out in the Woods | 80+ | PotM | Notrepere |
| Happy Sun Daycare | 80+ | PotM | Chelsea.adams.524 |
2015
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jeff the Killer 2015 | 290+ | Contest Winner | K. Banning Kellum |
| A Small Piece of Lead | 80+ | PotM | EmpyrealInvective |
| The Long List | 80+ | PotM, Suggested Reading, Contest Winner |
HumboldtLycanthrope |
| The Number of Darkness | 50+ | PotM | HumboldtLycanthrope |
| Mrfriend123 | 40+ | Justmeyall | |
| From Hell I Write | 40+ | Jake Wick | |
| Shut That Damned Door | 30+ | Spotlighted Pastas | Josh Parker (WriterJosh) |
| He Was a New Man | 30+ | HumboldtLycanthrope | |
| A Figure in the Fog | 30+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
Shadowswimmer77 |
| The Forest of Things You Want to Happen | 20+ | Spotlighted Pastas | Tiololo |
2016
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Why I Became an Atheist | 30+ | Spotlighted Pastas | RaydiantWon |
| The Brooding Star | 20+ | Spotlighted Pastas | Matthew Varney |
| In the Night Garden | 20+ | Shimoaoi | |
| The Children Found a Flower | 10+ | Spotlighted Pastas | SkullMunch |
| Her Red Right Hand | 10+ | Shadowswimmer77 | |
| Fleshgait | 10+ | EmpyrealInvective | |
| The Hell Inside My Head | 10+ | TheWizardOfTheWoods | |
| The Deaths of Lela and Raymond Howard | 10+ | Dr. Frank N. Furter | |
| Afternoon Tea | 10+ | Spotlighted Pastas | u/NP-CO |
| Give It Everything | 10+ | Spotlighted Pastas | ChristianWallis |
2017
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Girl in the Picture | 80+ | PotM | RaydiantWon |
| Charles Bonnet Syndrome | 20+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
u/Mr_Stuff |
| Heavy Rain | 20+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
TheDoctorFF |
| A Game of Tag | 20+ | PotM | Cainmak |
| The Gravedigger Had an Odd Conversation | 10+ | PotM | TheDoctorFF |
| She Was Asking for It | 10+ | Spotlighted Pastas | SirTobiasWade |
| The Bubble Brother's Happy-Happy Funhouse |
10+ | Reary77 | |
| How to Survive in Hell | 10+ | u/Ratrotted | |
| Burnin' Down the Ozarks | 10+ | PotM | Baron Fist |
2018
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| All Too Human | 40+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
Icydice |
| How to Beat the Sandman | 30+ | PotM | RedNovaTyrant |
| Another Senseless Ritual | 20+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
Icydice |
| A Mother's Obsession | 20+ | PotM | Nick Botic |
| The Old Bridge in the Park | 20+ | PotM | MoistSquelch |
| Send Me a Pic | 10+ | Jdeschene | |
| Sloppy Joes | 10+ | Kolpik | |
| Into the Psyche | 10+ | PotM | Kolpik |
| My Roommate Is into Some Weird Fairy Shit | 10+ | PotM | u/sleepyhollow_101 |
| Ball-Pit | 10+ | Icydice |
2019
| Page | Comments (rounded) | Special categories | Author/creator |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Backrooms | 220+ | Claykid12345 | |
| Lost Episodes Can Be Found Again | 80+ | PotM | HopelessNightOwl |
| Dear Theodore | 10+ | PotM, Suggested Reading |
SpiritVoices |
| I've Discovered a Horrifying Truth | 10+ | PotM | SpookFox |
| The Angelica Incident | 10+ | Cornconic | |
| Roses Don’t Belong on a Ford Mustang | 10+ | PotM | SawmillTurtle |
| Where the Birches Lean | 10+ | PotM | L0CKED334 |
| Easter at Uncle Danny's | 10+ | PotM | RedNovaTyrant |
| The Final Bus of Route 375 | 10+ |