It'd be nice to hear the original producer defend himself. I went to 14's site from here and it's amazing. It's a huge aching apology to gamers concerning the expectations that they have for Final Fantasy as a franchise.
The apology makes it feel like Square might really be feeling scared, embarrassed, and dishonoured. They've even replaced many of the top members on the 14 team.
"What were they thinking?" is what I want to know. Did the original producer not have the time, the team, the money? Or did he think that this type of gaming model would work? If so, I want to hear him defend his original vision for the game. Unfortunately he's not gonna quit or be fired. So he'll just keep his mouth shut and take the lumps the company wants him to take without letting us know exactly why the game he was in charge of sucked.
In light of this, I think it's imperative that good games be made by people who actually care about the world and the characters. In spite of budget or medium or technology, I think that audiences respond to heart, not format. Heart that gets to realize it's intention.