Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Gender neutral language within build instructions #6814

Closed
wants to merge 1 commit into from

Conversation

Tunas1337
Copy link

It's a minor nitpick, but I think it's important; assuming the user and/or developer of the operating system is male isn't exactly the best.

@awesomekling
Copy link
Collaborator

This project is not an appropriate arena to advertise your personal politics.

@Tunas1337
Copy link
Author

I had no intention to advertise anything, my bad. I thought it was a neutral enough change, but I do understand if it's necessary to discuss it further, or just not implement it whatsoever if you do not agree with it.

@Tunas1337 Tunas1337 deleted the mod-buildinstructions branch May 2, 2021 11:26
@cafkafk
Copy link

cafkafk commented Jul 2, 2024

hi fedi 👋

@MostAwesomeDude
Copy link

The denial of non-male users and/or developers is sufficient reason to not use SerenityOS. Thanks for documenting your beliefs clearly.

@cafkafk
Copy link

cafkafk commented Jul 2, 2024

The denial of non-male users and/or developers is sufficient reason to not use SerenityOS. Thanks for documenting your beliefs clearly.

check this as well #8046 (comment), totally cooked project

@dtfleetwood
Copy link

Yup, projects that defend dehumanization deserve to wither on the vine. Will see if the new leadership course corrects.

@rollerozxa
Copy link

If English is not your native language and you accidentally use gendered language directed at an undetermined person then that is understandable, but lashing out when someone contributes a change to correct it is just vile.

@Higgs1
Copy link

Higgs1 commented Jul 2, 2024

There's a report button. Good day.

@Syphist
Copy link

Syphist commented Jul 2, 2024

What a vile response and terrible look for you and your projects.

@Tunas1337
Copy link
Author

Tunas1337 commented Jul 2, 2024

OP here. I'd just like to chime in and say that it's been nearly 3 years and a month since I tried to make what I believed to be a minuscule neutral change entirely rooted in grammar, and not once have I touched this project until these replies brought it back into my attention. If the developer has a right to develop under the assumption that every user is male, I have the right to boycott the software. I don't know what "new leadership" is being talked about, as I haven't searched the web about it yet, but I also hope that they are more logical about issues like this.

(Also: hello github-drama people! I have no doubt this will end up being PR'd there in the next couple of days.)

@iskamag
Copy link

iskamag commented Jul 2, 2024

Good day fedi cat people. awesomekling, you're truly awesome :3
1c559886d46f5fbd

@mia-0
This comment was marked as a violation of GitHub Acceptable Use Policies
@alexispurslane
Copy link
Contributor

Every time some FOSS dev rejects a change from generic masculine the mastoqueers come crawling out of the woodwork to start screeching about how he’s literally Hitler. This is pathetic.

Who said that? This just sucks. I've been following kling, Serenity OS, and LadyBird for a very long time and I assumed they'd be better.

@cornfields74
Copy link

cornfields74 commented Jul 2, 2024

mastoqueers

i'm gonna start using this for myself now LMAO that's genuinely so funny

@MeowcaTheoRange
Copy link

Every time some FOSS dev rejects a change from generic masculine the mastoqueers come crawling out of the woodwork to start screeching about how he’s literally Hitler. This is pathetic.

bold of u to assume everyone here uses m*stodon 🤢🤢🤮🤮 /silly

@tulpenkiste
Copy link

Every time some FOSS dev rejects a change from generic masculine the mastoqueers come crawling out of the woodwork to start screeching about how he’s literally Hitler. This is pathetic.

bold of u to assume everyone here uses m*stodon 🤢🤢🤮🤮 /silly

Yeah, we all use queerkey here, smh >:3

@mia-0
This comment was marked as a violation of GitHub Acceptable Use Policies
@MeowcaTheoRange
Copy link

MeowcaTheoRange commented Jul 2, 2024

but yeah as a they/them user mysel it would be cool if this pull request was re-reviewed :3

like #24647

@tulpenkiste
Copy link

tulpenkiste commented Jul 2, 2024

Good job validating his views, I guess. Surely that’ll help.

That's the whole point of the toothpaste flag behavior though. Societally sanctioned harassment to fill the need of domination in the lack of any productive ways to do so.

Using the behaviour of an individual to demean an entire community is, quite frankly (and to put it lightly), pretty stupid and incredibly rude.

@SleepyCatgirl
Copy link

Every time some FOSS dev rejects a change from generic masculine the mastoqueers come crawling out of the woodwork to start screeching about how he’s literally Hitler. This is pathetic.

Good job validating his views, I guess. Surely that’ll help.

Some of you may be thinking there’s no arguing with such people but to be honest, I used to be like that, too. Sometimes much worse—fiercely “anti-woke”. And yet I’ve changed. Maybe he won’t, but brigading isn’t going to achieve anything but providing more ammunition.

We... really do need a better way of handling those issues to be honest. I mean... this is open source, this is about doing things together. And please, no one is screeching about how anyone is literally hitler. Just that... its disappointing.

@nukeop
Copy link

nukeop commented Jul 2, 2024

Mastodonites seething even after 3 years lol

@tulpenkiste
Copy link

Mastodonites seething even after 3 years lol

Not everyone here came from Mastodon

@MeowcaTheoRange
Copy link

Mastodonites seething even after 3 years lol

errm... gross...... 🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮 see above: #6814 (comment) (being even more silly rn)

@nukeop
Copy link

nukeop commented Jul 2, 2024

Ah okay so you're using mastodon with a changed logo and name

@MeowcaTheoRange
Copy link

Ah okay so you're using mastodon with a changed logo and name

Correct !!!! ✅✅✅✅✅✅✅

@K4rakara
Copy link

K4rakara commented Jul 2, 2024

I really should have specified on my fediverse post to not harass the guy about it. While I might disagree with his views and no longer wish to use his software, it was not my intent for people to harass him about his views. I simply wanted people to be made aware of it so they can decide whether it's a project they wanted to use or not. This is a three year old issue, and the outcome of it is not going to change.

@nukeop
Copy link

nukeop commented Jul 2, 2024

If this kind of thing is what makes you decide to use the project or not, you were not going to use it or even know what it is in the first place.

@MeowcaTheoRange
Copy link

I really should have specified on my fediverse post to not harass the guy about it. While I might disagree with his views and no longer wish to use his software, it was not my intent for people to harass him about his views. I simply wanted people to be made aware of it so they can decide whether it's a project they wanted to use or not. This is a three year old issue, and the outcome of it is not going to change.

yeah true
im just over here bring silly but i will Stop participating here cus yall are too Not silly for me to care :3 (and it'z actually filling up this thread and exploding in terms of github notifications)
so just see #6814 (comment) - im out :3

@4risu
Copy link

4risu commented Jul 2, 2024

Sunlight is the best disinfectant.
I tried being "understanding" of bullies for many years. It's easier... If people change that's good but I'm not waiting around.

@nukeop
Copy link

nukeop commented Jul 2, 2024

You all have 0 open source contributions and this guy built an entire OS by himself

@tulpenkiste
Copy link

tulpenkiste commented Jul 2, 2024

You all have 0 open source contributions and this guy built an entire OS by himself

What does this have to do with anything? Those who have not contributed code are still permitted to write issues for projects. To gatekeep such a thing worsens the reputation of open source.

Also, I have contributed to open source. :3

@TheEvilSkeleton
Copy link

TheEvilSkeleton commented Jul 2, 2024

You all have 0 open source contributions

Well, your commit number means very little in practice, because you don't have to be a developer to contribute to FOSS. You can work on documentation, designs, marketing, moderation, reporting issues, etc. etc.

Since you're comparing about FOSS contributions, you might want to look at my GNOME GitLab profile and acknowledge that I contribute to software used by millions of users :) https://gitlab.gnome.org/TheEvilSkeleton

But even then, many people may have 0 contributions because they don't want to deal with people who think that any kind of step toward inclusivity is "personal politics," when it's fundamentally collective politics of making it more welcoming for everyone else.

@isabelroses
Copy link

hi fedi 👋

Haiiii

P.S. Surprised this hasn't been locked yet lol

@tulpenkiste
Copy link

You all have 0 open source contributions

Well, your commit number means very little in practice, because you don't have to be a developer to contribute to FOSS. You can work on documentation, designs, marketing, moderation, reporting issues, etc. etc.
Since you're comparing about FOSS contributions, you might want to look at my GNOME GitLab profile and acknowledge that I contribute to software used by millions of users :) https://gitlab.gnome.org/TheEvilSkeleton
But even then, many people may have 0 contributions because they don't want to deal with people who think that any kind of step toward inclusivity is "personal politics," when it's fundamentally collective politics of making it more welcoming for everyone else.

^^ this, i don't even use github anymore

Nor do I

@tulpenkiste
Copy link

hi fedi 👋

Haiiii

P.S. Surprised this hasn't been locked yet lol

I imagine the project managers just aren't aware of whats going on yet

@RedCyberPandaz
Copy link

I wanna get in on this before it gets locked. Dev bad.

@MeowcaTheoRange
Copy link

MeowcaTheoRange commented Jul 2, 2024

hi fedi 👋

Haiiii

P.S. Surprised this hasn't been locked yet lol

I wanna get in on this before it gets locked. Dev bad.

even if it's not locked though I think the conversation here should Come to a halt. see #6814 (comment)

@SegoCode
Copy link

SegoCode commented Jul 2, 2024

Neither wrong or right, your project, your rules, and everyone can make the decision they want about contributing

@SerenityOS SerenityOS locked as too heated and limited conversation to collaborators Jul 2, 2024
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.