Freestyle Roasted Chicken Parm

Freestyle Roasted Chicken Parm
David Malosh for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Simon Andrews. Prop Stylist: Paige Hicks
Rating
4(1,719)
Notes
Read community notes

This is a no-recipe recipe, a recipe without an ingredients list or steps. It invites you to improvise in the kitchen.

You don’t need much for this easy dinner: bone-in chicken thighs, canned crushed tomatoes, mozzarella, a little Parmesan or pecorino, zest from a lemon, olive oil and red-pepper flakes, maybe a few snips of basil if you can find any. (If you can’t, don’t worry, it will still kill.)

Toss the chicken in salt, pepper, zest, red-pepper flakes and a few glugs of olive oil, then get them on a greased sheet pan or two in a 425-degree oven, skin-side up, spreading them out as much as you can manage. While the chicken roasts, warm the tomatoes on the stove with a splash of olive oil and a little black pepper. Watch the chicken get well and truly crisped — it’ll take around 35 or 40 minutes — and then place a nice slice of mozzarella on each one to melt. (Activate the broiler, if you like, but I prefer the gentle style.) Spoon warm tomato sauce onto each plate, then top with a cheese-covered chicken thigh, some sprinkled Parmesan and a few torn pieces of basil. Sautéed greens would go nicely on the side.

Sam Sifton features a no-recipe recipe every Wednesday in his What to Cook newsletter. Sign up to receive it. You can find more no-recipe recipes here.

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement

Ratings

4 out of 5
1,719 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

Think this recipe would have been better with skinless chicken breasts instead of thighs. Thigh skins were simply too fatty when mixed with the mozzarella. Everyone ended up peeling off the skin, and then having to place the melted cheese on top of the thighs—quite messy.

These non-recipe recipes are a bit terrifying for a newish cook like me, but this was great. My only improvisation/suggestion: added oregano, garlic, salt, pepper, and red pepper flakes to the tomatoes. I ended up being rather proud of the sauce as a result.

Never buy cheap meat, especially from place like costco. Animals should not be industrialized and tortured. Buy local. If you cannot afford it, buy small amounts. Industry fatm is no 1 cause of climate change and its immoral

Boneless chicken thighs with their skin intact are not easy to find, at least in the suburban supermarkets I patronize (e.g., Stop and Shop). If using boneless, skinless thighs, I'd recommend spooning some of the tomato sauce on each one before topping with the cheese, and then returning them to the oven briefly to melt and slightly brown the cheese.

For me, the best bite of a chicken parm is the gooey cheese combined with the crunchy breading on the chicken. Instead of putting the mozzarella on the chicken, I toasted some some sliced Levain (any good sourdough would work), rubbed it with a garlic clove, sprinkled with shredded mozzarella and Parmesan cheese, then broiled till just bubbly. Also used a jar of a favorite marinara sauce this time. So juicy crispy chicken, savory sauce and crunchy, cheesy bread. Lots of good bites!

What does thawed in freezer mean?

Costco’s frozen, boneless, skinless chicken breasts thawed in baking dish overnight in freezer. In evening while preheating oven to 450, pour organic marinara sauce, organic garlic and top with shredded organic kale. Bake for 20 minutes. Remove from oven, after cutting chicken to serving portions (2-3), transfer to plates. Sprinkle with Parmesan

Hysterical that the above comments are telling creative folks to follow the recipe - it's a no recipe recipe people - improvisation is good! :) Anyone try veal?

My hubby and I are foodies and cooks. He is also a trial lawyer-don't hold it against him, he is super cool. But he came home tonight after a long day in court and transit, and I had whipped this up with a nice green salad, and he just said, "This is one of the most satisfying meals I have had in some time-thank you!" Uh, yeah, you're welcome! I had made a mushroom marinara last night, and pulled some chicken out of the freezer and all else we had on hand. Make this for people you love.

Chicken thighs are laughably easy to bone. Turn it skin-side down, give the structure a good look, and you will see where to take your knife. When you put it on the pan, tuck the meat under the skin to make it look like it has no bone, or spread it out so it will cook faster.

If you do meal prep, there's really no reason to spend the money on store-bought marinara sauce. Twenty minutes and you can have your own homemade marinara sauce. Just follow the NYT's Classic Marinara Sauce recipe. Sooo . much better! https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1015987-classic-marinara-sauce

I baked the thighs on a parchment lined baking sheet. Then I took all the rendered fat and juice from the baking pan and whizzed it with an immersion blender into the tomato sauce. Also not noted in the instructions but clear from the photograph is to use fresh mozzarella. Delicious. I will definitely be adding this to the family dinner repertoire.

It was very easy to throw a half stick of butter and half an onion and some salt into the canned tomatoes a la Marcella Hazan for a delicious quick sauce to go with the chicken thighs. Since they did take 45 min and not 30 the sauce was finished when the chicken was done.

Here's a tip about chicky thighs. I needed to cook up a bunch for seniors, many of whom prefer boneless meats they can cut up easily. So, after checking with the meat department at Publix, I picked out 12 good-sized thighs from the case and requested that the bones be removed. About 15 minutes later, I went home with skin-on boneless thighs that cooked up nicely on the sheet pan, and then easily cut them to produce 24 servings for a potluck dinner. The butcher is your friend.

This was the bomb. Thank you Mr. Sifton.

Consider removing the chicken to a platter after baking with the cheese. Cover in foil and swirl some slices of focaccia or baguette in those pan juices, toast for a few minutes in the oven, and serve with your chicken. It doesn’t disappoint…

I did this with boneless skinless chicken breasts trimmed into roughly the size of thighs for a ‘oh hey plans changed tonight, what are we having for dinner?!!’ dinner. I used a glass baking dish in a convection oven at slightly lower temp. But will keep temp the same as per recipe next time! It was low stress, easy and even my slightly picky eaters (5 and 2 yrs old) enjoyed it along side some plain pasta noodles! Keeping this in the rotation!

Absolutely delicious! Used boneless skinless breasts, dipped in yogurt mixed w a little water (no buttermilk) and coated w breadcrumbs and then added salt, pepper, red pepper and lemon zest…also made the Marcela Hazaña tomato sauce which made the entire dish perfect. Baked 23 min then broiled once I added mozzarella. This will be a keeper.

I used nice thick slices of eggplant in place of chicken for vegetarian version. Lightly oil the slices no need to pre-salt or peel). Bake for 10 mins. Then proceed with the recipe.

Such a great payoff for so little work. This will be a new go-to in my kitchen. I used boneless skinless thighs. Mixed zest, grated garlic, salt, pepper, and pepper flakes with breadcrumps. Dredge each thigh in the crumbs and arrange on a large piece of foil on a baking sheet. Mound the remaining crumb mix on the thighs, drizzle with olive oil, fold the foil into a tent and bake at 350 for 20 minutes. Then open up, add a spoon of sauce and the cheese, then bake 15 more minutes.

Bone in chicken thighs? No - skinless chicken cutlets. Breaded and sautéed then baked in sauce and topped with mozzarella.

Sounds great--Let's have more freestyle recipes....Thanks!

Home made sauce, OG chicken breasts brined, first-rate cheese. I read all the comments and did my best. The chicken was dry. Chicken will never match my mother’s veal parm back in the day; that said, I doubt that breasts are the way to go now. I’ll try Sam’s way and apologize for doubting him.

This is love on a plate. I put a bit of basil pesto and tomato sauce under the cheese. Delicious.

I agree that this would be better with skinless chicken--probably breasts.

Made this with boneless skinless chicken breasts and it turned out great. The only thing I added were bread crumbs. Served with a side of pasta and green beans. Fussy husband was thrilled!

I used this basic idea with boneless breasts that I had breaded with egg, flour and breadcrumbs, then roasted with some olive oil. Added some mozzarella near the end. The cutlets stayed crispy and cheesy. Then served with a doctored jar of marinara. Thanks, Sam.

See? JBrian MADE chicken parm OUT OF this recipe...

This was delicious. Added a thin layer of breadcrumbs to the chicken and used provolone instead of mozzarella but otherwise prepared as directed. I think it would be equally good with chicken breast. Highly recommend.

We can’t get fresh local chicken. Aldi’s sells fine young chickens and parts, including boneless thighs. Young means smaller and more tender. Will be trying this soon.

An excellent ‘idea’ for chicken parmigiana. Enhanced the tomatoes with a little onion and garlic and my favorite spices. Thanks for the tip about cooking on parchment paper. I’ve discovered a great tip! Used bone-in thighs like recommended and sauce on the bottom. Great dish.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.