Port Toddy

Port Toddy
Sam Kaplan for The New York Times. Food stylist: Michaela Hayes. Prop stylist: Rebecca Conroy.
Rating
4(161)
Notes
Read community notes

A port toddy is one of winter’s unsung delights. Replacing whiskey with port in a toddy leads to something surprising and special. Somehow, it feels more curative than one with harder spirits: it’s like the alcohol-fortified equivalent of a bowl of homemade chicken soup. This requires a ruby port, which is the cheapest and most easily found. (The New York Times)

Featured in: Pour the Port, Hold The Stodginess

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement


Ingredients

Yield:1 serving
  • 3ounces ruby port (I like Fonseca or Taylor Fladgate, either of which would be good for the punch)
  • 1teaspoon brown sugar
  • 1teaspoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
  • 1teaspoon freshly squeezed orange juice
  • 1cinnamon stick
  • Water just off the boil
  • 11-inch-wide ribbon of orange peel studded with 3-5 cloves.
Ingredient Substitution Guide

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    In a mug or heatproof glass, stir the port, sugar and juices together with the cinnamon stick, leaving the cinnamon in the vessel. Add hot water to fill, and garnish with the clove-studded orange peel.

Ratings

4 out of 5
161 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

I love this recipe. The port gives the cocktail a deeper, roastier flavor than mulled wine. I typically use a bit of honey rather than brown sugar. I often put one slice of lemon and one slice of orange in each toddy, rather than using juice. I stick cloves in the slices. I’ve also multiplied this recipe for groups: in a slow cooker on warm, combine your full bottle of port, an equal portion hot water, one full sliced lemon and orange, honey, cinnamon sticks, and cloves in a tea steeper.

I put about 3 ounces hot water per serving.

Added half an ounce of rye to this which rounded out all the flavors.

This was lovely. But it really didn't need the sugar. We found it sweet enough with the juices and spices. Really comforting drink. Mmmmm.

I've made this probably 5-6 times and each time I use less and less of the ingredients. Studding orange peel and fresh squeezing juice and popping a cinnamon stick in really does make a delicious drink. By the end of a very large bottle of port we were just using a splash of orange juice with a squeeze of lemon + the boiling water and it was still very tasty! Much quicker than mulling wine and you can still use as many accoutrements from that process as you want.

Delicious! I only had Tawny Port (RP10) and it was fine. The second time around I used 2 ounces of port and doubled-up on the OJ (2tsp) for a lighter drink. Let the clove studded orange peel steep in the toddy before drinking.

Am I missing something with the ratios here? In my cup at least, the quantity of port vs water meant that it ended up lukewarm. Certainly no wafts of steam as pictured! But if I had used a larger mug to fit more boiling water, I'd imagine it quite dilute. Thinking about gently heating the mixture on the stove next time, might help the spices and zest infuse better as well.

A shortcut for a still excellent toddy is to use Trader Joe’s Harvest Tea. I added a bit of honey, boiling water, and then popped the tea bag in. Let it steep, then added the port (or whiskey) with a healthy dollop of lemon juice (maybe a tablespoon?). Very tasty!

This was great! Honestly the Port is sweet enough that you could do either no brown sugar or just a tiny bit. (also a squeeze of honey would be a good substitute) but overall amazing!

Bland, enjoy a nice glass of pure port instead!

Added a shake of orange bitters.

I've made this probably 5-6 times and each time I use less and less of the ingredients. Studding orange peel and fresh squeezing juice and popping a cinnamon stick in really does make a delicious drink. By the end of a very large bottle of port we were just using a splash of orange juice with a squeeze of lemon + the boiling water and it was still very tasty! Much quicker than mulling wine and you can still use as many accoutrements from that process as you want.

This is especially nice warmed in a sake warming pot over candles, so you get to pour tiny pottery cups of it from the pot as it warms.

This was lovely. But it really didn't need the sugar. We found it sweet enough with the juices and spices. Really comforting drink. Mmmmm.

I love this recipe. The port gives the cocktail a deeper, roastier flavor than mulled wine. I typically use a bit of honey rather than brown sugar. I often put one slice of lemon and one slice of orange in each toddy, rather than using juice. I stick cloves in the slices. I’ve also multiplied this recipe for groups: in a slow cooker on warm, combine your full bottle of port, an equal portion hot water, one full sliced lemon and orange, honey, cinnamon sticks, and cloves in a tea steeper.

Delicious! I only had Tawny Port (RP10) and it was fine. The second time around I used 2 ounces of port and doubled-up on the OJ (2tsp) for a lighter drink. Let the clove studded orange peel steep in the toddy before drinking.

Added half an ounce of rye to this which rounded out all the flavors.

I put about 3 ounces hot water per serving.

I followed your advice and that seemed to work well for me as well.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.