Coffee Cocktails That Aren’t an Espresso Martini

Coffee and alcohol are powerful forces on their own. Mix them together and you’ve got a recipe for greatness and a sweet buzz that will carry you through the night. Surely, at this point, you’ve tried an espresso martini – they’re hard to escape. And don’t get us wrong, they’re delicious and worthy of their “cocktail of the moment” status and hype. But maybe you’re feeling something a bit different in 2024. Something more nuanced, citrusy, or perhaps even more milkshake-y!

If you’re looking to expand your coffee cocktail repertoire, we’ve rounded up some of our favorite coffee-infused cocktail recipes that you can make at home – or order at the bar. There’s a variety of coffee cocktails with different flavor profiles in our list. For those who like a more bitter, complex flavor, try the cold brew Negroni. For those who prefer a creamy and sweet concoction, you can’t go wrong with a White Russian or a frozen mudslide! If you don’t want to be buzzing all night (and staring up at the ceiling come bedtime), just opt for decaf and you can still enjoy a great coffee-flavored cocktail.

Read on for 11 caffeinated cocktails to jolt your evening alive.

RumChata Iced Latte

Image Credit: Snacks and Sips.

If you’re not familiar with RumChata, it’s a cream liqueur made from rum, cream, cinnamon, and other spices. This cocktail features a classic iced latte with an added splash of RumChata and topped with a cinnamon whipped cream. Perfect for an afternoon pick me up.

Get the recipe from Snacks and Sips.
Siciliano

Image Credit: Creators of Coffee.

With a clean, bittersweet flavor and an extra caffeine boost, the Siciliano is a contemporary black coffee cocktail recipe with classic Italian flavors.

The combination of sweet vermouth, amaro liqueur and fresh coffee results in a delightful Italian coffee cocktail that makes a perfect after dinner digestif.

Get the recipe from Creators of Coffee.
Carajillo

Image Credit: The Novice Chef.

This popular Mexican coffee cocktail features Licor 43, a Spanish liqueur made with vanilla, cinnamon and orange peel. Espresso, Licor 43, ice and sugar get shaken up iand poured over ice for a flavorful and rich coffee cocktail.

Get the recipe from The Novice Chef.
Affogato Martini

Image Credit: A Flavor Journal.

Espresso martinis are fantastic, but what happens when you add gelato and a few more complex flavors to the mix? Magic is what happens. The affogato martini takes things to the next level and is a coffee-lover’s dream cocktail.

Get the recipe from A Flavor Journal.
Kahlúa Coffee

Image Credit: A Couple of Cooks

Kahlúa coffee is the perfect brunch drink or after dinner treat served with a dollop of whipped cream. The key to this simple drink is brewing an excellent cup of coffee.

Get the recipe from A Couple of Cooks.
Coffee Old-Fashioned

Image Credit: Feast and West

Wake up your senses with an aromatic coffee old-fashioned. Made with coffee liqueur and coffee bitters, the classic bourbon cocktail is just as lovable with a buzz of caffeine!

Get the recipe from Feast and West.
Frozen Mudslide

Image Credit: Cupcake Project.

The classic mudslide drink is the perfect marriage of Baileys Irish Cream liqueur and Kahlúa. This version also has vodka and vanilla ice cream in the mix and gets blended up with ice for a heavenly boozy milkshake.

Get the recipe from Cupcake Project.
White Russian

Image Credit: Food with Feeling

This three-ingredient classic cocktail – made with vodka, Kahlúa, and heavy cream – is the perfect pick me up and delivers all the cozy vibes.

Get the recipe from Food with Feeling.
Black Russian

Image Credit: Mix That Drink

The Black Russian is about as simple of a cocktail as it gets. You combine vodka and Kahlúa over ice – that’s it. But don’t let the simplicity fool you – it’s a rich, delicious cocktail.

Get the recipe from Mix That Drink.
Irish Coffee

Image Credit: Sugar and Soul.

Irish Coffee is a traditional cocktail made with coffee, whiskey, brown sugar, and whipped cream. This spiked coffee is perfect for weekend brunch and dessert.

Get the recipe from Sugar and Soul.
Cold Brew Negroni

Image Credit: Ave Styles.

This balanced cocktail is big on convenience. Grab some cold brew from your fridge and if you’ve already got the ingredients for a negroni on hand (sweet vermouth, Campari, and gin), you’re ready to imbibe.

Get the recipe from Ave Styles.
Pin it!

Save these recipes to Pinterest for later!