Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

The Hunt

He Tested His $450,000 Budget All Over New York: Would It Be Williamsburg, Hell’s Kitchen or the South Bronx?

For his first home purchase, a resourceful renter stockpiled a down payment and looked for the ideal spot to invest it.

Connor Krone with Harry near his new apartment in the city. Aiming to make his first home purchase a solid investment, Mr. Krone looked in Brooklyn, Manhattan and the Bronx for the right space at the right price.
Andrea Mohin/The New York Times

For a year before he moved to New York, Connor Krone drove across the country in a camper van that he built himself. When he finally arrived, as Covid was waning, he spent four more months in the camper van, parking on the street in various non-Manhattan neighborhoods.

Mr. Krone — who basically transformed a delivery van into a mini-apartment — used a composting toilet and showered at the gym. He even had a three-camera security system and a temperature monitor for when he had to leave his dog, Harry, alone.

“People live in New York in really creative ways, and this is maybe an extreme example,” Mr. Krone, 37, said. “The camper van was more livable than people would imagine.”

[Did you buy a home in the past year? We want to hear from you. Email: thehunt@nytimes.com]

But eventually he needed something bigger and stationary, so he moved into an artists’ warehouse in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, where he paid $1,800 a month. With 900 square feet, it could fit gym equipment, power tools and art made by his grandfather, a painter and illustrator. Mr. Krone did woodworking projects and helped friends build furniture.

Last year, he sold the camper van for $110,000, more than doubling his investment, and put the proceeds in tech stocks, aiming to amass a down payment for his first home purchase.

“Connor was concerned with long-term appreciation and whether he would get a return on his investment,” said his real estate agent, Matthew Bank, of Bank Neary Real Estate, whom he met through a friend at a gay pride event.

Connor Krone, with Harry, in the camper van that he retrofitted before moving to more stationary acommodations.
Patrick Botticelli/New Jersey Outdoor Adventures

Mr. Krone, who is from San Francisco, works in corporate philanthropy. His office is in the financial district, and he wanted a place near a useful subway line for a manageable commute. His budget ranged up to $450,000.

“Connor didn't have a particular neighborhood in mind,” Mr. Bank said. “Because of his budget, which was not very high for New York City, we talked about the differences between buying a market-rate apartment and an H.D.F.C. apartment.”

So Mr. Krone considered some income-restricted H.D.F.C. co-ops, which often had temptingly low monthly maintenance charges, but also high flip taxes when sold. He was more than willing to downsize, always keeping trade-offs in mind. “Moving to a smaller space was a commitment to get a gym membership and store my grandfather’s art, which were extra costs,” he said.

Among his options:

No. 1

Grand Concourse Two-Bedroom

Andrea Mohin/The New York Times

This renovated 1,150-square-foot two-bedroom in a prewar building in the Bronx was a sponsor unit, requiring no board approval. It had a large foyer, two hallways, an eat-in kitchen with a dishwasher, six closets and open views of the Grand Concourse. The building had a basement laundry room and was a block from the D, B and 4 trains, but it would still take him an hour to get to work from there. The asking price was $425,000, with monthly maintenance of around $1,200.

(virtually staged)

No. 2

Hell’s Kitchen One-Bedroom

Andrea Mohin/The New York Times

This 450-square-foot one-bedroom was in an H.D.F.C. co-op over retail storefronts in a 19th-century building on Ninth Avenue, not far from Times Square. The railroad-style unit had exposed brick, high ceilings, a decorative fireplace and built-in shelving, but no bedroom closet. The building offered basement storage, free laundry and a furnished roof deck. The price was $450,000, with monthly maintenance of less than $400.

No. 3

South Williamsburg One-Bedroom

Andrea Mohin/The New York Times

This sunny 500-square-foot one-bedroom was on the fifth floor of a walk-up H.D.F.C. building near the foot of the Williamsburg Bridge. The layout was unconventional, with a long entry hall, one closet and a narrow bedroom. The windowed kitchen had a dining nook, a washer and dryer, and shelves rather than cabinets. The J, M and Z trains stopped a couple of blocks away. The price was $410,000, with maintenance in the high $500s.

Find out what happened next by answering these two questions:

Which Would You Choose?

0%

Grand Concourse Two-Bedroom

0%

Hell’s Kitchen One-Bedroom

0%

South Williamsburg One-Bedroom

Which Did He Buy?

0%

Grand Concourse Two-Bedroom

0%

Hell’s Kitchen One-Bedroom

0%

South Williamsburg One-Bedroom