MLB
The Athletic's trade graders look back at the grades that didn't quite land from the 2023 trade deadline.
The Athletic MLB Staff33
The move boosts Milwaukee's (51-35) starting rotation, which ranks near the bottom in innings pitched.
Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon124
In a perfect world, the Guardians would have slotted Civale behind Shane Bieber and Triston McKenzie as they marched toward the postseason.
Zack Meisel141
It is a little surprising that Aaron Civale netted just one prospect considering he is a starter with two years of control remaining.
Keith Law86
The Rays fortified a rotation that has been beset with injuries all season; the Guardians got back a potential .300-.320 hitter.
The Athletic MLB Staff113
Civale, 28, has a 2.34 ERA with a 5-2 record in 13 starts this season.
The Athletic Staff140
There’s clearly a scarcity of sellers in this trade-deadline market. That’s why Civale would be a prized target.
Zack Meisel131
No negativity, for once. Only the positives here. Consider it a palate cleanser before the second half begins.
Zack Meisel54
Here are some reasons why the Guardians, who are still in the contention in the AL Central, are three games below .500.
Zack Meisel84
McKenzie posted a 2.96 ERA last season, with 190 strikeouts and an opponent average of .201. Civale has a 2.84 ERA.
Zack Meisel32
A Guardians pitcher suggested that someone in the rotation added a pitch to their arsenal during the offseason. Let the hunt commence.
Zack Meisel21
Yankees hitters will bat against Civale at least once, and the Guardians' playoff lives will depend on his keeping them in the yard.
Joe Vardon17
The last man standing from the Opening Day rotation, Civale, is the Indians' latest starting pitching casualty. Yet somehow they're 40-30.
Zack Meisel39
He's quiet. He's smart. And he's been Cleveland's staff anchor after overhauling his motion in the offseason. Meet The Chemist.
Zack Meisel25
Al Melchior looks at the sustainability potential for six pitchers who have had early success despite lower than expected CSW rates.
Al Melchior5
It'll take more than five starting pitchers to survive the 2021 season. It always does. How can Cleveland's rotation shoulder the load?
Zack Meisel26
Nate Pearson's debut for the Blue Jays did not disappoint, and the team should have a No. 1 starter in him, if not now then soon.
Keith Law58