Last updated on Jul 22, 2024

You're facing conflicts between patients and their families. How can you navigate care decisions effectively?

When it comes to healthcare, the patient's needs and preferences should always be at the forefront. However, conflicts between patients and their families can arise, especially when it comes to care decisions. As a healthcare professional or patient advocate, navigating these situations effectively is crucial to ensure the patient's wishes are respected while maintaining a supportive environment for everyone involved.

1 Understand Rights

Understanding the rights of patients is the first step in resolving conflicts. You should be well-versed in patient rights, which include the right to participate in their own healthcare decisions, the right to privacy, and the right to receive information about their condition and treatment options. When a disagreement occurs, remind all parties of these rights and ensure that the patient's voice is heard. It's important to balance family concerns with the patient's autonomy and to mediate discussions with empathy and respect for everyone's perspective.

Add your perspective

Mark Porterfield, Owner

Owner at Care♥avan NEMT Transports
Report contribution
One thing we always do when entering a patient's room is to make sure we greet them first. We introduce ourselves, then to the rest of the family. Not only is this the courteous thing to do, it shows the patient that they are valued. It also lets them know (and the family) they are included in any conversation we may have about them. Understanding patients rights is essential in healthcare, ensuring they receive respectful, quality treatment. Basic rights include the right to informed consent, to access medical records, and to refuse treatment or seek second opinions. Although family members can make great advocates, they may not always agree with their loved ones wishes. That's where effective communication comes in, such as a will.

Like

Unhelpful

2 Clear Communication

Clear communication is key in any conflict resolution. Listen actively to both the patient and their family members, acknowledging their emotions and concerns. Provide information in a way that is understandable to non-medical individuals, avoiding jargon that could lead to misunderstandings. Encourage open dialogue, allowing each party to express their views without interruption. By facilitating a space where everyone feels heard, you can help bridge gaps in understanding and foster a collaborative approach to care decisions.

Add your perspective

3 Mediate Disputes

Mediating disputes requires patience and neutrality. Your role is to help both sides reach a common ground while keeping the patient's best interest at heart. Start by identifying the root of the conflict and then explore possible solutions together. Sometimes, bringing in a neutral third party, such as a social worker or a mediator trained in healthcare disputes, can help facilitate a resolution. Remember, the goal is not to win an argument but to find a care plan that respects the patient's wishes and provides peace of mind for the family.

Add your perspective

4 Legal Considerations

Legal considerations can often complicate care decisions. If a patient has an advance directive or a legally appointed healthcare proxy, these documents should guide decision-making. It's crucial to explain the legal implications of these documents to all involved parties and ensure that they are followed. If there is no advance directive in place and the patient is unable to communicate their wishes, family members may need to make decisions on their behalf. In such cases, it's important to work with legal counsel to understand the hierarchy of decision-makers under state law.

Add your perspective

Klaus Dieter Girnt

Vorstand bei lightzins eG
Report contribution
Zu "guten" bzw. "gesunden" Zeiten sollte grundsätzlich eine wirksame (notarielle) Vorsorgevollmacht erstellt werden. Rechtliche Überlegungen können dann eliminiert werden. Der Staat kann aus der Privatsphäre herausgehalten werden.

Translated

Like

Unhelpful

5 Support Systems

Leverage support systems to help manage conflicts. Healthcare institutions often have resources like patient advocacy departments, ethics committees, or pastoral care services that can provide additional support. Encourage families to utilize these resources for guidance and counseling. Additionally, support groups and community resources can offer comfort and advice from others who have faced similar situations. By connecting patients and families with these networks, you can help them find strength and understanding outside of the clinical setting.

Add your perspective

Klaus Dieter Girnt

Vorstand bei lightzins eG
Report contribution
Die lightzins eG in Bochum bietet als Assistenzgenossenschaft Ihren Mitgliedern und Mandantinnen und Mandanten ein geeignetes Netzwerk und Verbindungen zur notwendigen Unterstützung.

Translated

Like

Unhelpful

6 Decision Making

Finally, when it comes to making decisions, prioritize a consensus that upholds the patient's values and desires. Facilitate family meetings where everyone involved can discuss options with the healthcare team. Use decision aids if necessary to visually outline the benefits and risks of different treatments. Ensure that all parties understand that while the decision process is democratic, the patient's preferences are paramount. By doing so, you can help navigate a path forward that honors the patient's autonomy while respecting family input.

Add your perspective

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

Klaus Dieter Girnt

Vorstand bei lightzins eG
Report contribution
Rechtzeitig sollte jeder Mensch, verbunden mit einer qualifizierten Beratung, rechtzeitig entscheiden, wie, wodurch und wer ihn im Falle einer persönlichen Beeinträchtigung im vermögensrechtlichen und persönlichen Bereich vertreten soll.

Translated

Like

Unhelpful

Load more contributions

You're facing conflicts between patients and their families. How can you navigate care decisions effectively?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Understand Rights

2 Clear Communication

3 Mediate Disputes

4 Legal Considerations

5 Support Systems

6 Decision Making

7 Here’s what else to consider

Patient Advocacy

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Patient Advocacy

More relevant reading

You're facing conflicts between patients and their families. How can you navigate care decisions effectively?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Understand Rights

2 Clear Communication

3 Mediate Disputes

4 Legal Considerations

5 Support Systems

6 Decision Making

7 Here’s what else to consider

Patient Advocacy

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

Explore Other Skills