Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

    Smarter: How to Prevent Knee Pain

    woman holding painful knee Photo: Adobe Stock

    This week I’m looking into common causes of knee pain and how we can prevent it. Also in this issue: What is top-tier gas, and—there’s no delicate way to put this—are pet feces compostable? 


    THE BIG STORY:

    ‘Knee I Remind You’

    Have you ever experienced knee pain? In our Instagram poll, 90 percent of participants, unfortunately, said yes. I have had knee pain on and off for the past 10 years. It’s never so painful that it’s debilitating, but it’s definitely enough to be annoying.

    To stop the gnawing pain from emanating from my left knee ever again, I asked experts about the things we can do to prevent knee pain.

    More Tips From the Smarter Newsletter

    First of all, what causes knee pain?
    The most common causes of knee pain are associated with aging, injuries, or overuse, according to the website for Johns Hopkins Medicine, a hospital in Baltimore. 

    For instance, knee problems can come from osteoarthritis, a wear-and-tear condition that occurs when knee cartilage deteriorates with age and use. You can also have knee pain from rheumatoid arthritis, a disease that causes inflammation of the joints, including your knees. 

    Injuries that can cause knee pain include a sprained or strained knee ligament or muscle, or torn cartilage. It can also come from tendonitis, the overuse and inflammation of your tendons during certain activities such as running, jumping, or cycling, according to Johns Hopkins Medicine. 

    What factors could be contributing to the risk of knee pain?
    Weakness and underuse of the muscles that support the knees are common causes of inflammation that can result in pain, says Ashley V. Austin, MD, a sports medicine physician at the Hospital for Special Surgery in New York City.

    When our core muscles, glutes, quadriceps, and hamstrings are weak, we make compensatory movements that put abnormal stress across our joints, including the knees, says Cody C. Wyles, MD, an orthopedic surgeon at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn.

    High-impact activities, such as running or high-intensity interval training, which is short bursts of intense exercise alternated with brief recovery periods, can also contribute to knee pain if they’re done without proper training, Ashley says. 

    That’s especially the case if those high-impact activities are coupled with shoes that don’t support you, inadequate nutrition, and repetitive stresses from the same activity over time without sufficient rest periods. 

    What are ways we can help prevent knee pain?
    Exercise. Staying active is crucial for knee health. You can try exercises such as glute bridges, single-leg deadlifts, and eccentric sideboard leg curls, which can strengthen and stabilize your lower body and the areas around your knees, says Dan McGinley, a coach at Mike Boyle Strength & Conditioning, a fitness and training facility in Woburn, Mass.

    You should listen to your body and avoid doing exercises that hurt your knees, Dan says. And in addition to strength training, it’s important to engage in various activities that involve cardiovascular fitness, stability, and mobility, Cody says. 

    Cardiovascular exercise involves anything that elevates your heart rate. Stability work with balance exercises and core strengthening are easy to incorporate at the end of a workout. Also, don’t forget to stretch, because tight muscles fatigue easier and can lead to injuries around the knees.

    Knee pain can arise from increasing the load on your knees faster than your knees can adapt, for example, running too often or quickly without adequate recovery time. Therefore, make sure your exercise program gradually increases activity in a manner that’s safe and effective, says Kelcie Wittman, PT, a specialist in sports physical therapy in Colorado Springs, Colo., and spokesperson for the American Physical Therapy Association.

    If you’re already experiencing pain, avoid high-impact activities such as running, jumping, deep knee bends, and squats. Instead, try low-impact activities such as walking on soft surfaces like a track, grass, and trails, Ashley says. Other options include swimming, aquatic exercise, tai chi, modified yoga, recumbent biking, and exercising on an elliptical machine. 

    If you’re looking to purchase an elliptical, here are the best ellipticals of 2023, according to our tests (available to CR members).

    Use proper form. When you’re doing activities such as squatting, lunging, and going up and down stairs, make sure you’re not leaning forward too much on your toes with your upper body bent forward, says Jeremy A. Alland, MD, a sports medicine physician at Midwest Orthopaedics at Rush, an orthopedic clinic in Chicago. 

    Instead of putting all the pressure on the front of our feet, we should position ourselves more toward the middle of our feet or our heels, and keep our back upright, Jeremy says. 

    Wear supportive shoes for daily activities and exercise, Ashley says. For your running shoes, you want to make sure they fit well and have good cushioning, according to Penn Medicine. And if you have flat feet, you might want to try special shoe inserts and arch support. 

    Maintain a healthy weight. Excess pounds is one of the most common reasons for knee pain and can contribute to arthritis. To track your fitness progress or body weight better, check out our ratings of the best fitness trackers and bathroom scales (available to CR members).

    Physical therapy treatments. If you’re already experiencing knee pain, physical therapists can provide personalized information on the best ways to relieve it as well as identify habits that may be contributing to the pain that you’re unaware of, Kelcie says. 

    Bonus reading: How to treat pain in your knees, feet, back, and head. And if you’re looking to do some strength training, here are four easy strength training moves.


    You’re reading Smarter, a newsletter that answers consumer questions with useful tips from our experts. Sign up to get Smarter in your inbox or check out more Smarter issues here.


    LOL

    When we asked Instagram users what helped them prevent knee pain from happening again, regular exercise, strength training, and physical therapy were some of the most common answers.

    But we also got some funny responses that we just can’t get out of our heads. One person, for instance, said, “I punched my knee really hard and it went away haha true story.” Sounds likely.


    QUIZ

    Yes or no: Are pet feces compostable? 


    ASK AN EXPERT

    Cocoa Nibs on a Gold Spoon

    Photo: Michelle Lee Photography/Getty Images Photo: Michelle Lee Photography/Getty Images

    Question from reader Brad Winter: 
    I read your article about the presence of cadmium and lead in dark chocolate. Do the same guidelines exist for cocoa nibs as they do with dark chocolate?

    Answer:
    While we didn’t test cocoa nibs, they do contain higher levels of cocoa solids, which may contain cadmium and lead, says Kevin Loria, the CR health writer who reported the article on dangerous heavy metals found in dark chocolates

    Because of that, it would be reasonable to apply the same guidelines to them that you would to dark chocolate, Kevin says. Consider them a treat, don’t eat excessive quantities every day, and think about how they factor into your overall chocolate consumption.

    There are also multiple ways in which heavy metals can contaminate dark chocolate. Read more about how lead and cadmium end up in dark chocolate in the first place.

    Do you have any health or food safety questions? Ask our experts anything.


    MUST-READS OF THE WEEK

    🔎 The Truth About Artificial Sweeteners
    They’re in more foods than you might realize.

    🏦 How to Break Up With Your Bank
    We know it’s Valentine’s Day, but some hard conversations must happen.

    🍕 Best Frozen Pizzas
    And a top-selling frozen pizza brand we’re okay to skip.

    👩‍⚕️ Your Guide to Cholesterol Control
    And should you start taking statins?

    ❤️ The Cars People Love Most (available to CR members)
    Here are the cars that people found to be most and least satisfying, according to our annual survey.


    THE GOOD STUFF

    What is top-tier gas, exactly?

    @consumerreports Is top tier gas worth the extra money? See the latest episode of Talking Cars through the link in our bio. #carsoftiktok #cartok #carcommunity #gas ♬ original sound - Consumer Reports

    And is it worth the extra price? Here’s what we say.


    QUIZ ANSWER

    The answer is … it depends on the composting system you’re using. 

    Pets feces aren’t compostable if you’re composting at home using either a backyard compost bin or vermicomposting, which is the breaking down of organic waste with worms. The feces might contain pathogens you wouldn’t want in your compost.

    If your composting is part of a large-scale system, such as one organized by your city to collect food scraps, or if you pay a service that picks up organic waste, then it’s a different story. These systems heat up to high temperatures that will kill dangerous pathogens, so pet feces are generally okay.

    But! It’s important to check with that system first to see if it accepts it. And if you’re collecting your pet feces in a bag, make sure the bag is compostable before you toss it in.

    Read more to see if items such as bones, meat, and paper plates are actually compostable. 


    Owl Icon

    "Consider this newsletter a long overdue Valentine’s card to my knees."


    Thanks for reading Smarter! If you want more tips that will make you a little bit smarter, sign up to have the newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every week.



    Headshot of CR Author Pang-Chieh (BJ) Ho

    Pang-Chieh Ho

    Pang-Chieh Ho is a senior content creator at Consumer Reports who writes about the intersections of home products and health. She has been working in the media industry for almost 10 years. Books are her first love, but movies come a close second. You can send tips to her at pangchieh.ho@consumer.org.