Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

    Ring Ends Controversial 'Request for Assistance' Tool Used by the Police

    The tool, built into Ring's mobile apps, made it easy for law enforcement to ask Ring users to share video footage

    Video Doorbell Pro 2 on door. Photo: Ring

    Amazon’s home security subsidiary Ring announced today that it is sunsetting its Request for Assistance (RFA) tool that the police have used to request video footage of alleged crimes from Ring doorbell and camera owners. 

    The tool was part of Ring Neighbors, a kind of neighborhood-watch social network available as a stand-alone smartphone app and as part of the Ring app. On the platform, users can post videos from their Ring doorbells and cameras, as well as pictures and videos from other devices. Request for Assistance, which made it easy for police departments to ask Ring users for video clips, had drawn criticism from digital and civil rights groups. 

    “The ability for law enforcement to use the Neighbors app to mass-request footage from camera owners was always dangerous, and had a documented effect of exacerbating racial profiling,” says Evan Greer, director of Fight for the Future. The organization has criticized Amazon’s use of police partnerships to promote its products and favors strict laws on where cameras can be placed to protect the privacy of neighbors. 

    More on Digital Security & Privacy

    Police and fire departments will still be able to use the Neighbors network to “share helpful safety tips, updates, and community events” but not to request and receive videos, according to a company statement. The police can request video from people without using the app, for instance by door-to-door canvassing. Additionally, law enforcement can still obtain footage from Ring directly through mechanisms such as search warrants. 

    This is the latest move by Ring to address criticism of its law enforcement partnerships. The company had partnered with over 2,500 local law enforcement agencies, over 570 fire departments, and 12 local government agencies when we last tallied them in April 2023.

    In 2021, Ring completed a two-year audit of its Neighbors network with the New York University School of Law Policing Project. It made the Request for Assistance tool more transparent by using public posts on the network rather than having Ring privately email camera users on behalf of law enforcement. But those changes didn’t resolve all of the concerns of privacy and civil rights advocates.

    In 2022, Ring and other home security camera manufacturers were criticized after sharing video footage with law enforcement without a warrant or user consent by using an exception in the federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA), which allows manufacturers to provide information without delay in instances involving life-threatening emergencies.

    For more information on how the police can acquire your camera footage, see our guide to what to do if the police ask for your security camera or doorbell recordings.


    Daniel Wroclawski

    Daniel Wroclawski

    Dan Wroclawski is a home and appliances writer at Consumer Reports, covering products ranging from refrigerators and coffee makers to cutting-edge smart home devices. Before joining CR in 2017, he was an editor at USA Today’s Reviewed, and launched the site’s smart home section. In his spare time, you can find him tinkering with one of the over 70 connected devices in his house. Follow Dan on Facebook and Twitter @danwroc.