The purpose of this study was to evaluate how currently used helmets would perform for winter play activities, such as tobogganing. In Canada and northern parts of the US, the advent of winter is followed by an increase in visits to hospital emergency departments by young children presenting with head injuries resulting from winter activities. Sliding, skating, skiing, and snowboarding all involve risks of head injury from situations such as falling on ice or sliding into stationary objects. This study compared the protective characteristics of helmets used by young children (< 7 years of age) participating in winter recreational activities.
Ice hockey, alpine ski, and bicycling helmets were impacted at 2.0, 4.0, 6.0, and 8.0 m/second at the front and side impact location by using a monorail drop rig.
The results for the front impact showed that the ice hockey helmet protected the child significantly better at 2 and 4 m/second when considering both linear and angular peak acceleration. The bicycle helmet performed significantly better than the other 2 helmets at 8 m/second for the front location and only angularly for the side impacts.
Depending on the impact velocity of the hazard, the type of helmet significantly affected the risk of brain injury.
Please include this information when citing this paper: DOI: 10.3171/2011.11.PEDS11299.
American Society for Testing and Materials: F1045-06 Standard Performance Specification for Ice Hockey Helmets West Conshohocken, PA, ASTM International, 2006. DOI: 10.1520/F1045-06
American Society of Testing and Materials: F2040-11 Standard Specification for Helmets Used for Recreational Sport Helmets West Conshohocken, PA, ASTM International, 2006. DOI: 10.1520/F2040-11
Bernardo LM, , Gardner MJ, & Rogers KD: Pediatric sledding injuries in Pennsylvania. J Trauma Nurs 5:34–40, 1998
Björnstig U, & Tordai P: Tobogganing and sledding accidents. Mechanisms and injuries. Scand J Soc Med 14:83–86, 1986
Canadian Standards Association: CAN/CSA-D113.2-M89 Cycling Helmets. A National Standard of Canada (Reaffirmed 2004) Etobicoke, ON, Canadian Standards Association, 1996
Canadian Standards Association: CAN/CSA-Z263.1-07 Recreational alpine skiing and snowboarding helmets Etobicoke, ON, Canadian Standards Association, 2007
Canadian Standards Association: Z262.1-09 Ice Hockey Helmets Etobicoke, ON, Canadian Standards Association, 2009
Cimpello LB, , Garcia M, , Rueckmann E, & Markevicz C: Sledding: how fast can they go?. J Trauma 66:3 Suppl S23–S26, 2009
Corra S, & De Giorgi F: Sledding injuries: is safety in this winter pastime overlooked?. A three-year survey in South-Tyrol. J Trauma Manag Outcomes 1:5, 2007
Dershewitz R, , Gallagher SS, & Donahoe P: Sledding-related injuries in children. The Pediatric Forum 144:1070–1073, 1990
European Committee for Standardization: EN 1080:1997. Impact Protection Helmets for Young Children European Committee for Standardization, 1997
Gennarelli TA, , Ommaya AK, & Thibault LE: Comparison of translational and rotational head motions in experimental cerebral concussion. 15th Stapp Car CrashConference Proceedings, 17–19 November 1971, Coronado, California New York, Society of Automotive Engineers, 1971. 797–803
Gimbel GM, & Hoshizaki TB: Compressive properties of helmet materials subjected to dynamic impact loading of various energies. Eur J Sport Sci 8:341–349, 2008
Hackam DJ, , Kreller M, & Pearl RH: Snow-related recreational injuries in children: assessment of morbidity and management strategies. J Pediatr Surg 34:65–69, 1999
Hedges JR, & Greenberg MI: Sledding injuries. Ann Emerg Med 9:131–133, 1980
Holbourn AHS: Mechanics of head injury. Lancet 2:438–441, 1943
Kim PC, , Haddock G, , Bohn D, & Wesson D: Tobogganing injuries in children. J Pediatr Surg 30:1135–1137, 1995
Lee F, , Osmond MH, , Vaidyanathan CP, , Sutcliffe T, & Klassen TP: Descriptive study of sledding injuries in Canadian children. Inj Prev 5:198–202, 1999
Major CP, , Guest DP, , Smith LA, , Barker DE, & Burns RP: Sledding injuries in the southeastern United States. South Med J 92:193–196, 1999
Manary MJ, & Hollifield WC Jr: Childhood sledding injuries in 1990–91. Pediatr Emerg Care 9:155–158, 1993
Mertz HJ, , Prasad P, & Irwin AL: Injury risk curves for children and adults in frontal and rear collisions (SAE 973318). 41st Stapp Car Crash Conference Proceedings, November 1997, Lake Buena Vista, Florida Society of Automotive Engineers, 1997. (http://papers.sae.org/973318/;WebLogicSession=Z1ZJTLlTWwXg6wzYVxn13vvGLMCy3pXJJdQzsWv0hbFV1f42DDNs!1181765704) [Accessed November 22, 2011]
Noffsinger D, , Nuss K, , Haley K, & Ford N: Pediatric sledding trauma: avoiding the collision. J Trauma Nurs 15:58–61, 2008
Ortega HW, , Shields BJ, & Smith GA: Sledding-related injuries among children requiring emergency treatment. Pediatr Emerg Care 21:839–843, 2005
Padgaonkar AJ, , Krieger KW, & King AI: Measurement of angular acceleration of a rigid body using linear accelerometers. J Appl Mech 42:552–556, 1975
Sallee D, , Moore M, & Johnson M: Traumatic brain injuries in Alaska, 1996–1998. Alaska Med 42:37–40, 2000
Shorter NA, , Mooney DP, & Harmon BJ: Childhood sledding injuries. Am J Emerg Med 17:32–34, 1999
Skarbek-Borowska S, , Amanullah S, , Mello MJ, & Linakis JG: Emergency department visits for sledding injuries in children in the United States in 2001/2002. Acad Emerg Med 13:181–185, 2006
Sloan JP, , Maheson M, & Dove AF: How dangerous is sledging?. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 290:821, 1985
Snell Memorial Foundation: 1995 Standard for Protective Headgear, 1998 Revision: For Use in Bicycling Snell Memorial Foundation, North Highlands, CA, 2000. (http://www.smf.org/standards/pdf/b95rev.pdf) [Accessed November 22, 2011]
Snell Memorial Foundation: 1998 Standard for Protective Headgear: For Use in Recreational Skiing and Snowboarding North Highlands, CA, Snell Memorial Foundation, 1998. (http://www.smf.org/standards/pdf/rs98std.pdf) [Accessed November 22, 2011]
Verrees M, , Robinson S, & Cohen AR: Sledding accidents in children: potential for serious injury, risk of fatality. Pediatr Neurosurg 40:2–7, 2004
Wynne AD, , Bota GW, & Rowe BH: Sledding trauma in a northeastern Ontario community. J Trauma 37:820–825, 1994
Zhang L, , Yang KH, & King AI: A proposed injury threshold for mild traumatic brain injury. J Biomech Eng 126:226–236, 2004
Yoganandan N, , Pintar FA, , Sances A Jr, , Walsh PR, , Ewing CL, & Thomas DJ, et al.: Biomechanics of skull fracture. J Neurotrauma 12:659–668, 1995
All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
---|---|---|---|
Abstract Views | 2737 | 1077 | 91 |
Full Text Views | 137 | 11 | 0 |
PDF Downloads | 229 | 6 | 0 |
EPUB Downloads | 0 | 0 | 0 |