Stimulant users caught up in fatal 'fourth wave' of opioid epidemic

In Pawtucket, R.I., near a storefront advertising “free” cell phones, J.R. sat in an empty back stairwell and showed a reporter how he tries to avoid overdosing when he smokes crack cocaine.

(NPR is identifying him by his initials because he fears being arrested for using illegal drugs.)

It had been several hours since his last hit, and the chatty, middle-aged man’s hands moved quickly. In one hand, he held a glass pipe. In the other, a lentil-sized crumb of cocaine.

Or at least J.R. hoped it was cocaine, pure cocaine — uncontaminated by any fentanyl, a potent opioid that was linked to nearly 80% of all overdose deaths in Rhode Island in 2022.

He flicked his lighter to “test” his supply. If it has a “cigar like sweet smell,’’ he said, it means that his cocaine is laced with “fetty” or fentanyl. He put the pipe to his lips and took a tentative puff. “No sweet,” he said, reassured.

But this “method” he devises offers only false — and dangerous — reassurance. It’s actually impossible to tell for sure if a drug contains fentanyl by the taste or smell. And a mistake can be fatal.

“Somebody can believe that they can smell it [fentanyl] or taste it, or see it…but that's not a scientific test,’’ said Dr. Josiah “Jody” Rich, an addiction specialist and researcher who teaches at Brown University. “People are gonna die today because they buy some cocaine that they don't know has fentanyl in it.’’

The mix of stimulants like cocaine and methamphetamines with fentanyl – a synthetic opioid 50 times more powerful than heroin – is driving what experts call the opioid epidemic’s “fourth wave.” The mixture presents powerful challenges to efforts to reduce overdoses, because many users of stimulants don’t know they are at risk of ingesting opioids and so don’t take overdose precautions.

The only way to know if cocaine or other stimulants contain fentanyl is to use drug-checking tools such as fentanyl test strips – a best practice for harm reduction now embraced by federal health officials for combating drug overdose deaths. Fentanyl test strips cost as little as $2 for a two-pack online, but many front-line organizations also give them out for free.

In the U.S., the first wave of the long-running and devastating opioid epidemic began with the abuse of prescription painkillers (early 2000s); the second wave involved an increase in heroin use, starting around 2010.

The third wave began when powerful synthetic opioids like fentanyl started appearing in the supply around 2015.

Now experts are observing a fourth phase of the deadly epidemic. Nationwide, illicit stimulants mixed with fentanyl were the most common drugs found in fentanyl-related overdoses, according to a study published in 2023 in the scientific journal Addiction. 

The stimulant in the fatal mixture tends to be cocaine in the Northeast, and methamphetamine in the West and much of the Midwest and South.

“The number one thing that people in the U.S. are dying from in terms of drug overdoses is the combination of fentanyl and a stimulant,’’ said Joseph Friedman, a researcher at UCLA and the study’s lead author.

“Black and African Americans are disproportionately affected by this crisis to a large magnitude, especially in the Northeast.’’

Factors driving polydrug overdoses

It’s not clear how much of the latest trend in polydrug use is accidental or intentional. A recent study from Millennium Health found that most people who use fentanyl do so at times intentionally and other times unintentionally.

People often use stimulants to power through the rapid withdrawal from fentanyl, Friedman said. And the high-risk practice of using cocaine or meth with heroin, known as speedballing, has been around for decades.

Other factors include manufacturers adding the cheap synthetic opioid to a stimulant to stretch out their supply, or dealers mixing up bags.

But in Rhode Island, researchers said, many people still think they are using unadulterated cocaine or crack — a misconception that can be deadly.

Stimulant users unprepared for fentanyl's ubiquity

“Folks who are using stimulants, and not intentionally using opioids, are unprepared to respond to an opioid overdose…because they don't perceive themselves to be at risk,’’ said Jaclyn White Hughto, a Brown University epidemiologist and a principal investigator in a new, unpublished study called Preventing Overdoses Involving Stimulants.

The researchers surveyed more than 260 people in Rhode Island and Massachusetts who use drugs, including some who manufacture and distribute stimulants like cocaine.

More than 60% of the people they interviewed in Rhode Island had bought or used stimulants that they later found out had fentanyl in them.

In 2022, Rhode Island had the fourth highest rate of overdose deaths involving cocaine in 2022, after D.C., Delaware and Vermont. according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

People who don't regularly use opioids have lower tolerance, which puts them at higher risk of an overdose.

And many of the people interviewed in the study also use drugs alone, so if they do overdose they may not be found until it’s too late.

Dubois was a single mother raising two Black sons. The older son, Clifton, had been struggling with addiction since he was 14, she said. Clifton also had been diagnosed with ADHD and a mood disorder.

Back in March 2020, Clifton had just checked into a rehab program as the pandemic ramped up, Dubois said.

Because of the lockdown at rehab, Clifton was upset about not being able to visit with his mother. “He said, ‘if I can’t see my mom, I can’t do treatment,’” Dubois recalled. “And I begged him” to stay in treatment."

But soon after, Clifton left the rehab program. He showed up at her door. “And I just cried,” she said.

Dubois’s younger son was living at home. Dubois didn’t want Clifton doing drugs around his younger brother. So she gave Clifton an ultimatum: “If you want to stay home, you have to stay drug free.”

Clifton went to stay with family friends, first in Atlanta, and later in Woonsocket, an old mill city that has Rhode Island's highest rate of drug overdose deaths.

In August of 2020, Clifton overdosed but was revived. Clifton later confided that he’d been snorting cocaine in a car with a friend, Dubois said.

Hospital records show he tested positive for fentanyl.

“He was really scared,” Dubois said. After the overdose, he tried to “leave the cocaine and the hard drugs alone,’’ she said. “But he was taking pills.”

Eight months later, on April 17, 2021, Clifton was found unresponsive in the bedroom of a family member’s home.

The night before, Clifton had bought counterfeit Adderall, according to the police report. What he didn’t know was that the Adderall pill was laced with fentanyl.

“He thought by staying away from the street drugs…and just taking pills, like, he was doing better,’’ Dubois said. “I do truly believe Cliff thought he was taking something safe.”

The opioid epidemic is driving up the mortality rate among older Black Americans (ages 55-64) and, more recently, Latinx people, according to a study recently published in The American Journal of Psychiatry.

But it’s too simplistic to merely focus on whether fentanyl is present, or not, said Joseph Friedman, the researcher at UC San Diego and the study’s author.

For years, hospitals have safely used medical grade fentanyl for surgical pain because the potency is strictly regulated.

“It's not the strength of fentanyl, that's risky,’’ he said. “It's the fact that the potency fluctuates wildly in the illicit market.”

Studies of street drugs, he said, show that in illicit drugs the potency can vary from 1% to 70% fentanyl.

“Imagine ordering a mixed drink in a bar and it contains one to 70 shots,’’ Friedman said, “and the only way you know is to start drinking it…There would be a huge number of alcohol overdose deaths.’’

Drug checking technology can provide a rough estimate of fentanyl concentration, he said, but to get a precise measure requires sending drugs out to a laboratory.

Fentanyl test strips offer a low-cost way to prevent overdoses by detecting the presence of fentanyl, regardless of potency, in cocaine and other illicit drugs.

In Rhode Island, the test kits are available for free from harm reduction groups such as Project Weber/Renew.

But the test strips only work if people use them – and then don’t consume the drugs if they test positive for fentanyl. And not enough people who use stimulants do.

This story comes from NPR's health reporting partnership with The Public's Radio and KFF Health News.

Transcript

JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:

Last year, the number of Americans who died from drug overdoses averaged almost 300 a day. A growing number of those deaths involved the use of stimulants like cocaine and methamphetamine. And this new wave of the overdose epidemic is taking an especially big toll on Black and Latino men. Lynn Arditi with The Public's Radio in Rhode Island has the story. And a warning - it contains a scene of illegal drug use.

LYNN ARDITI, BYLINE: Jennifer Dubois says her teenage son Clifton didn't think of himself as an opioid user. He took pills.

JENNIFER DUBOIS: Because in his eyes, he's doing Adderall. He's doing cocaine. He's not doing heroin. He doesn't do that.

ARDITI: She says, that's why he didn't take overdose precautions. One night, he bought a counterfeit pill from a dealer in Woonsocket, R.I. It was sold as Adderall but laced with fentanyl.

DUBOIS: And he thought, in his mindset, he was doing better because this is a prescription. But he was getting it from off the street.

ARDITI: Clifton Dubois died the next morning. He was 19. Clifton was also Black. By 2020, the year he died, the rate of fatal overdoses among Black men in America had more than tripled. They're casualties of what many call the fourth wave of the opioid epidemic. The first wave was prescription painkillers; the second, heroin; and the third, synthetic opioids like fentanyl. In this fourth wave, stimulants sold on the street are often mixed with fentanyl.

JODY RICH: People are going to die today because they buy some cocaine that they don't know has fentanyl in it.

ARDITI: Dr. Jody Rich is an addiction specialist at Brown University. Rhode Island has one of the highest rates of fatal overdoses involving cocaine.

RICH: If you're using cocaine every day, and then one day it's cocaine plus fentanyl, that could be enough to kill you because you don't have any tolerance.

ARDITI: People who use coke and meth aren't taking precautions that a lot of regular opioid users have learned to do, like carrying the opioid reversal medication Narcan, not using drugs alone and testing their drugs for fentanyl. Lex Morales works with the Rhode Island harm-reduction group Project Weber/Renew. He says, they get alerts from the state about fentanyl and other contaminants in the drug supply.

LEX MORALES: We get all that information, and we tell our clients, like, this is what's going on. This is what's in the supply right now.

ARDITI: Every morning in downtown Providence, his group's outreach workers go to a bus depot. They hand out Narcan and fentanyl test kits.

MORALES: They come to the van. They know who we are. And they just grab the supplies, and they know.

ARDITI: To test a stimulant for fentanyl, you take a tiny crumb and mix it with a little water. Then you dip in the test strip for a full minute. I wanted to see for myself, so I went to a neighborhood where a lot of drug users hang out.

I met a chatty middle-aged Latino man, J.R. NPR is using his initials because he uses illegal drugs. J.R. said he wanted to show me a method he has for smoking crack without overdosing. I followed him around the corner to an empty stairwell. He put a crumb of crack the size of a lentil in his glass pipe. He flicked his lighter and held the flame underneath.

J R: When you do this, and when you see that there's smoke (ph), and you see the smoke, just smell. See that cigar-like, sweet smell? It got fentanyl in it.

ARDITI: He claimed, if the cocaine smells sweet, that means it's been mixed with fentanyl. But he said if it doesn't, if it's - just smells like coke, then he thinks it's fine.

J R: You know what I mean? If it smells like coke, you good.

ARDITI: But you're not good. This method will not work. It's impossible to detect fentanyl by how a drug smells or tastes. And a mistake could be fatal. J.R. didn't overdose that day. He was lucky. He knows about fentanyl test kits, and he uses them sometimes, but not this time, which shows that getting people to test their drugs every time is going to take a lot more work.

For NPR news, I'm Lynn Arditi in Providence, R.I.

SUMMERS: This story comes from NPR's partnership between The Public's Radio and KFF Health News.

(SOUNDBITE OF NAV AND DON TOLIVER SONG, "ONE TIME")