Must be a bug. So sorry that happened. We will look into it.

Originally posted by tyler:

Must be a bug. So sorry that happened. We will look into it.

Hopefully you're still looking into this. I also sold all the fish, got the prompt that he wouldn't take more, and the achievement didn't unlock.

While I'm commenting, I think the game is great! I'll echo what others have said about an in-game tracker for heart pieces and stamina pieces. I have 18 and 3/4 hearts and no idea how much stam (missing one stam piece for the next upgrade). I suspect I'm very close to 100%. Thanks for at least putting some maps on a pinned post!

bumping... every once in awhile I check here to see if anything has been patched or fixed on this... I want to play the rest of the game but am worried the rest of my achievements wont trigger ... same as Jhops- he won't take more and the achievement didn't unlock. Also second that the game is great!

Just checkin in again, can this be fixed? make it so if you have them all on login the achievement bumps ?

....just... checking in again... Any response to a fix for broken fish achievement? patch that looks at if you have the all of the fish and dings it? just...asking... ;)