One Dolphin in All the Stars

1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna
shadoedseptmbr
charlottan

i honestly cant believe the normal amount of wanting to be another gender is zero. like arent you sick of yours yet lol

charlottan

cis ppl how often do you consider being different gender/less gender/more gender

never

every few years

about once a year

about once a month

once or twice a week

daily

not cis

See Results
charlottan

people with cis mutuals rb this pleeeeaseee

spaced0lphin

This may surprise you, but the normal amount to think about yourself as the opposite sex is… as often as you yourself happen to think about it. Lots of cis people I know think about it, or, if they don’t now, then they went through intense times of questioning it. Especially when they were quite young (IE under 25) and establishing an adult sense of self identity. Conditions like autism also increase the likelihood of a person exploring their relationship to gender in more detail.

I see a lot of cute, snappy rhetoric flying about that amounts to “thinking about this at all ever means you must be trans! Congrats on cracking your egg!”

Listen, there’s obviously nothing wrong with being trans. Let’s just establish that right away. Something I don’t see discussed at all though, is how there is also nothing wrong with going through this process of questioning, enjoying exploration, having an atypical relationship with gender, and still identifying as cis. Cis doesn’t translate to “boring.” There are so many ways to be what and who you are. Anyone who tells you otherwise is being a bit of a binarist, which is kind of the opposite of rainbow flag ideology as I have always understood it.

You can go through life and think about this stuff, often, and it means exactly as much or as little as you want it to mean, in the grand scheme of things. Better questions to ask yourself that can lead to a more advanced insight are things like, when you think about yourself as the opposite sex, what are you imagining yourself to be doing? What about your life is different? What are the experiences you hope to have? Is there a way to have those experiences now? If not, why? If so, why?

Transition is going to be right for some people. For most people, it’s going to be about taking the time to get to know yourself well, and seeing how all those interacting aspects fit within your life.

I am a woman. I was born that way. For about 7 years, I lived my young adult life as a man. I used a male name, wore binders and packers, identified as trans, participated in society as a guy to the best of my ability. I’m glad for the things I learned about myself and my identity during that time. One of the most important things I learned was that I didn’t have to change just to be me, and that I could be myself successfully even when those around me refused to agree with my self-perception. I learned that there are more important things in life than what existed or not between my legs, and how others chose to define me was neither in my control, nor was it particularly important. I came to understand my reactions to things and the source of them. I became comfortable with my body as it is, and accepted that I didn’t need to fit into anyone’s stereotype to be a woman. Being a woman is the least interesting thing about me. Being a gender is the least interesting thing to me about anybody else, by the same token!

Sometimes when I explain this, I get told that I was never really trans, and to those people, I offer an emphatic “fuck off.” I absolutely was. I know in my heart what I was thinking and how I felt. For 7 years. That’s not an insignificant amount of time and energy.

I also know that if the idea had been offered to me that who I was, how I was, was already good enough, that I might not have felt such a powerful desire to change into something else. If I’d been told that I didn’t need to fit into anybody else’s conception of what a man or a woman was, maybe I wouldn’t have tried so hard to.

Think about yourself as the opposite sex as much as you want. Explore it as much as you need. It doesn’t need to define you, unless you decide it is a defining characteristic.

gender less gender
dduane
bliss-bliss-bliss-bliss

image

Fanfolks today need to remember how important The Premise was.

Y'all have heard of The Premise, right?

See, historically there have always been people who saw an extra layer of gayness on certain pairs of fictional people (you just thought of several), and people Back Then even wrote their own fanfic (or as they were called at the time, "pastiches"), but the first widespread queer fanwork to really define the fanfiction genre was KIRK AND SPOCK. Kirk/Spock. K/S. The very first slashfics.

Why this work was vastly, overwhelmingly written by straight women is a discussion for another time, but it was, so that's the main perspective I'm gonna consider here.

image

How do you - a statistically middle-class, 30+, stay-at-home wife and mother - how do you write slashfic ao3-style in the 1960's before the internet?

Carefully.

Through letters with friends, phone calls, pen pals, and sometimes - sometimes - clandestine meetings of small groups. Whole novels were written communally, round-robin style, by sending typed or handwritten additions chapter by chapter to each other. These were all underground, some deep underground; even the early Trekkie fanzines of the time wouldn't touch them.

And keep in mind, few of these stories were explicitly even sexual! But they were all about a very, very close relationship between two men. In the 1960's.

Guess how cool everyone else was about this.

Actually, for their part, Gene Rodenberry and the other writers were fine with it, saying that they had deliberately written the characters to be two halves of a whole, and if you wanna read it that way, yeah sure, go right ahead. Shatner and Nimoy took it all in good humor, and seemingly still do, each guy basically gesturing to the other and chuckling "I mean, who wouldn't?"

But elsewhere there was vicious backlash against The Premise, and not just within the fandom. This was still at a time in the US and UK when various "sodomy" and "decency" laws made no distinction between homosexual sex acts and just, like, directly lighting another man's cigarette with your cigarette in public. (That, sadly, is not a fucking joke.)

It was probably the closest some suburban cishet women came to understanding the pain of being in the closet. They had to protect this secret from their friends and family at all cost. There were cases of divorces where women lost custody of their children because their writing had come to light.

image

Can you imagine having such a burning desire to write for your OTP that you were willing to lose everything over it? Even if you were never caught, you still had to be willing to wait weeks, months, to receive a letter in the mail that you had to carefully intercept, read in secret, and then add your own chapter t, also in secret, and then send off, perhaps never to be seen again.

These people were goddamn heroes, and they laid the foundation for the world we live in today. A world where we can read, write, comment on, or share - in a matter of seconds! - literature about two background characters from two different franchises enjoying a really specific kink involving vacuums or something. And that's objectively amazing.

Raise a toast to our fanfiction elders, who simped in the darkness so we could simp in the light of day.

iliadette

This is important and should have more notes.